Court Upholds Suswam’s Victory in Benue North-East APC Primary, Declares Substitution Unlawful

Legal Nigeria

Court Upholds Suswam’s Victory in Benue North-East APC Primary, Declares Substitution Unlawful

A court gavel

The Federal High Court in Abuja has affirmed former Benue State Governor, Gabriel Suswam, as the validly nominated candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) for the 2027 Benue North-East Senatorial District election.

Justice Inyang Ekwo, in a judgment delivered on Wednesday, November 18, declared that Suswam won the party’s senatorial primary conducted on May 18, 2026, and that his subsequent replacement with incumbent Senator Emmanuel Udende was unlawful.

The suit, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, was instituted by Suswam against the APC, Udende and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).

The former governor had approached the court after the APC allegedly substituted his name with that of Udende despite his victory at the primary.

Results presented before the court showed that Suswam polled 131,083 votes, while Udende secured 1,364 votes.

Suswam asked the court to nullify the substitution and compel the APC and INEC to recognise him as the party’s duly nominated candidate for the senatorial district.

INEC report supports Suswam’s claim

During the proceedings, INEC’s counsel, Anthony Malik, SAN, told the court that the commission’s documents and monitoring report confirmed Suswam as the winner of the primary.

Malik urged the court to determine the dispute based on the official records of the exercise.

Suswam’s counsel, Jibrin Okutepa, SAN, also urged the court to grant the reliefs sought by his client and dismiss the preliminary objections raised by the APC and Udende.

However, counsel to the APC, A. G. Yirvoms, asked the court to uphold the party’s objections and dismiss the suit.

In its judgment, the court rejected the defendants’ preliminary objections, holding that Suswam had the legal standing to challenge the outcome of a primary election in which he participated.

Justice Ekwo maintained that where an aspirant alleges that a party primary violated the Electoral Act, the party’s constitution or relevant guidelines, the court can exercise jurisdiction to examine the complaint.

The judge also held that the dispute could not be dismissed simply as an internal affair of the political party.

Court orders APC to submit Suswam’s name to INEC

On the substantive issues, the court held that the documentary evidence established Suswam’s victory and that the defendants failed to produce a different result capable of displacing the INEC report.

Justice Ekwo further faulted the party’s appeal committee report, which was dated May 18, the same day the primary was conducted.

He observed that there was no evidence that Suswam was given an opportunity to be heard before the decision that led to his substitution.

The judge consequently held that replacing Suswam with Udende violated his right to fair hearing and was inconsistent with the Electoral Act, the 1999 Constitution, as amended, and the APC constitution.

The court granted the reliefs sought by the former governor and ordered the APC to immediately forward his name to INEC as its validly nominated candidate for the 2027 Benue North-East senatorial election.

INEC was also directed to publish Suswam’s name as the party’s candidate for the district.

The judgment resolves the dispute over the APC senatorial ticket, with Suswam emerging as the candidate recognised by the court for the forthcoming election.

CONTACT LEGAL NIGERIA

Legal Nigeria welcomes partnerships, sponsorships, advertisements, press releases, event coverage, and article submissions from law firms, institutions, corporate organisations, and members of the legal community.

Contact:
📞 +234911456840
📧 legalnigeria@gmail.com

Support Independent Legal Journalism
Legal Nigeria Publications and Services
Access Bank (NGN): 1401825229
Access Bank (USD): 1773748357

Your support enables us to provide credible legal news, insightful analysis, and timely updates that keep the legal profession informed.