Court Nullifies Ribadu’s Candidacy, Orders INEC to Recognise Suleiman as ADC Governorship Candidate

Legal Nigeria

Court Nullifies Ribadu’s Candidacy, Orders INEC to Recognise Suleiman as ADC Governorship Candidate

adc

The Federal High Court in Abuja has nullified the emergence of Tukur Ribadu as the African Democratic Congress (ADC) governorship candidate for Adamawa State, ordering the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to recognise Omar Suleiman as the party’s candidate.

Justice Obiora Egwuatu, who delivered the judgment, held that the party had no valid basis for replacing Suleiman, who won its governorship primary, with Ribadu.

The judge directed the ADC to forward Suleiman’s particulars to INEC for publication as its governorship candidate, while restraining the electoral commission from recognising or publishing Ribadu’s name as the party’s flagbearer.

He also restrained Ribadu from parading himself as the ADC governorship candidate for Adamawa State.

The judgment followed a suit instituted by Suleiman, challenging the party’s decision to substitute him despite his victory at the primary election.

Suleiman argued that his replacement was not supported by any valid appeal process or lawful decision capable of overturning the outcome of the primary.

Court dismisses preliminary objections

Before determining the substantive case, Justice Egwuatu dismissed preliminary objections filed by the ADC and Ribadu, who challenged the competence of the suit.

The defendants argued that the case was incompetent, statute-barred and an abuse of court process. They also contended that Suleiman failed to exhaust the party’s internal dispute-resolution mechanism before approaching the court.

The court rejected the arguments, holding that the plaintiff instituted the action within the constitutionally prescribed timeframe.

Justice Egwuatu also dismissed an objection concerning the length of Suleiman’s written address, which exceeded the prescribed limit by two pages, saying striking out the suit on that basis would not serve the interests of justice.

The judge further held that requiring Suleiman to exhaust the party’s internal mechanisms could have caused the expiration of the 14-day constitutional period for filing pre-election matters.

Court finds no evidence of valid appeal

In determining the substantive dispute, the court examined whether Ribadu had successfully challenged the primary election result before a properly constituted appeal committee.

The ADC and Ribadu had argued that an appeal was lodged, reviewed by the party’s appeal committee and subsequently presented to the National Working Committee, which adopted a resolution on May 29 recognising Ribadu as the candidate.

However, Justice Egwuatu said documentary evidence before the court did not establish that Ribadu had submitted a petition to an appeal committee or that such a committee had determined the petition in his favour.

The court also considered affidavits from the chairman and secretary of the ADC Adamawa State Governorship Primary Election Committee, who denied that an appeal committee had been constituted to review the primary election.

The primary election committee’s report equally indicated that no petition had been received before the submission of its report.

Consequently, the judge held that Suleiman was the lawful winner of the party’s governorship primary and that the ADC had no valid basis for replacing him with Ribadu.

Suleiman wins primary with 143,216 votes

Suleiman, a former Managing Director of the Nigerian Ports Authority and former Nigerian Ambassador to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, defeated Ribadu and another aspirant, Umar Uba, in the ADC governorship primary conducted in May.

He secured 143,216 votes across the 21 local government areas of Adamawa State, while Ribadu polled 56,801 votes and Uba garnered 20,343 votes.

The results were announced by the chairman of the ADC Adamawa State Governorship Primary Committee, Nicholas Msheliza, who declared Suleiman the winner.

The party’s national leadership subsequently endorsed Ribadu as its governorship candidate, prompting Suleiman to approach the court to challenge the substitution.

In the judgment, Justice Egwuatu nullified Ribadu’s emergence and ordered the ADC to submit Suleiman’s particulars to INEC for publication as its candidate for the Adamawa governorship election.

The court also barred INEC from recognising Ribadu as the party’s candidate and restrained him from presenting himself as its governorship flagbearer.

CONTACT LEGAL NIGERIA

Legal Nigeria welcomes partnerships, sponsorships, advertisements, press releases, event coverage, and article submissions from law firms, institutions, corporate organisations, and members of the legal community.

Contact:
📞 +234911456840
📧 legalnigeria@gmail.com

Support Independent Legal Journalism
Legal Nigeria Publications and Services
Access Bank (NGN): 1401825229
Access Bank (USD): 1773748357

Your support enables us to provide credible legal news, insightful analysis, and timely updates that keep the legal profession informed.